芦笛外国文学论坛

标题: M.H. Abrams: Great Romantic literature scholar [打印本页]

作者: 怀抱花朵的孩子 时间: 2006-5-22 23:35
标题: M.H. Abrams: Great Romantic literature scholar
Honored literary scholar M.H. Abrams continues his labors (of love)
Professor Emeritus M.H. Abrams is author of the acclaimed The Mirror and the Lamp: Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition and editor of the Norton Anthology of English Literature, which he conceived. Robert Barker/University Photography

By Linda Grace-Kobas
Anyone whose book has been selected as one of the best of the 20th century could be forgiven for putting on a few airs. After all, such an honor is a sign of permanence as well as excellence.

But having his acclaimed book of literary criticism, The Mirror and the Lamp: Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition, ranked as No. 25 in the Modern Library's list of the 100 best nonfiction books written in English during the past 100 years doesn't seem to have fazed M.H. (Mike) Abrams at all. He thoughtfully waits outside his new home to meet a reporter, lest she get lost in the rambles of Ithaca's Kendal community. And he's even developed a self-effacing sound bite for the honor: "Shucks, it's only a century. Now, if it had been a millennium!"

This response would not surprise Abrams' colleagues at Cornell. While the Class of 1916 Professor of English Literature Emeritus is among the most highly regarded literary scholars of our time, he is appreciated among Arts faculty here for being a modest and wise man, as well.

"[Mike's] constant presence in the halls of Goldwin Smith reminds us all that scholarship is a labor of love, not a 9-to-5 job," said Jonathan Culler, chair of the Department of English. "During the culture wars and arguments about the literary canon, he has promoted here at home an open-mindedness and mutual respect that has often been lacking elsewhere."

Abrams' legacy to Cornell is deep and abiding. He was a founder of the A.D. White Center for the Humanities, which brings scholars from around the world to campus. He has been a staunch supporter of the University Library, chairing membership drives and establishing an endowment that resulted in the recent acquisition of a unique set of volumes of William Wordsworth's Poetical Works (1827), with copious emendations by the poet which have been unknown to scholars before now.

Abrams' literary legacy is vast, as well. Among his accomplishments and honors are these:

His best-of-the-century book The Mirror and the Lamp, a classic in literary theory, received the Phi Beta Kappa Christian Gauss Prize in 1954. "It was a groundbreaking book about changes in the conception of literature which came to fruition in the Romantic period," Culler said. "It's a work of intellectual history that took literary theory seriously and examined the crucial role of metaphorical models in the writing, reading and interpreting of literature."

He conceived and edited The Norton Anthology of English Literature in 1962. The seventh edition of these massive two volumes will be released this fall.

He's written six books, including Natural Supernaturalism: Tradition and Revolution in Romantic Literature, which won the James Russell Lowell Prize in 1972, and edited six others.

His numerous honors include the Award in Humanistic Studies from the American Academy of Arts and Sciences (1984), the Distinguished Scholar Award by the Keats-Shelley Society (1987) and the Award for Literature by the American Academy and Institute of Arts and Letters (1990).
Now 86 years old, Abrams isn't about to rest on his impressive laurels. He's spent much of the last two years revising the seventh editions of his Norton Anthology and his Glossary of Literary Terms. He's published an essay in a new book by the University of Massachusetts Press, The Persistence of Poetry: Bicentennial Essays on Keats. He's preparing to present the Harder Lecture, sponsored by the English department and Cornell Plantations, in the fall (tentatively titled, "This Green World," quoted from Wordsworth). And he wants to learn how to use a computer.

In a recent interview, Abrams displayed interests that range from the early Romantic poets to rap.

Whom does he read? "John Updike is always fun. And one of my former students, Tom Pynchon. I like to read [Cornell professor and poet] Archie Ammons, my great friend. And Harold Bloom, another former student."

Abrams was disappointed that several books he most highly regards were not on the Modern Library list.

"When I was a graduate student, the leading spirits at Harvard were interested in the history of ideas," he said. "Three books were almost student bibles: Science in the Modern World by Alfred North Whitehead, who taught at Harvard while I was a student there. [He is on the list at No. 23 for Principia Mathematica with Bertrand Russell.] The other two of the trilogy were E.A. Burtt's The Metaphysical Foundations of Modern Science, which I think is a classic. He was a philosopher at Cornell who did splendid work. The other book is by the great Cornell historian Carl Becker, The Heavenly City of the Eighteenth Century Philosophers. Becker's paradoxical undertaking was to show that the theories of the major philosophers of the 18th century secular enlightenment were biblical and theological in spite of themselves. He opened up a way of thinking which, looking back, I find had a great influence on me."

Born in Long Branch, N.J., on July 23, 1912, Abrams graduated from public high school and went to Harvard, where he earned his A.B. (1934), A.M. (1937) and Ph.D. (1940) in 18th and 19th century literature, literary criticism and European Romanticism. He was a Henry Fellow at Cambridge University in 1934-35.

Despite his literary specialization, Abrams worked as a scientist in classified research during World War II.

"The Psycho-Acoustic Laboratory was a supposedly secret lab in the basement of Memorial Hall at Harvard," he said.

His wife of 62 years, Ruth Claire Gaynes, also was employed there as a civilian. "We worked on solving the problem of voice communications in a noisy military environment. We developed tests for communications equipment, established military codes that are highly audible and invented selection tests for personnel who had a superior ability to recognize sound in a noisy background caused by engines and gunfire."

What qualified him for that job? His interest in psychology and the phonetics and philology courses he took to satisfy the old-fashioned requirements for a doctorate in English literature, he said.

Right after the war, Abrams was offered a job at Cornell. He was "charmed" by his first sight of the campus and Ithaca. Ruth, he jokes, being from New York City, "thought Ithaca was the end of the world." But, she learned to love it, too.

Moving from war science back to literature was "quite a shock." Abrams had begun working on The Mirror and the Lamp in Cambridge in the mid-'30s and went back to it. "The book didn't appear until 1953," he said. "Most of it was rewritten half a dozen times. Hard work makes easy reading or, at least, easier reading."

That book won instant acclaim.

"I've always been surprised at the degree of success of The Mirror and the Lamp and the range and duration of esteem for it," Abrams commented. "I had no reason to expect in 1953 that it would appeal to more than a specialized group interested in literary criticism. I think one of the reasons why it's been of interest to a broad spectrum of readers is because one of its emphases was on the role of metaphors in steering human thinking. It was a very early book to insist on the role of metaphors in cognition, as well as in imaginative literature -- to claim that key metaphors help determine what and how we perceive and how we think about our perceptions."

Abrams confessed that, to his mind, his book Natural Supernaturalism is "more important" than his more acclaimed work. One of its chief emphases, he explained, is the profound influence of biblical and theological literature on secular thinking, literature and the writing of history. "Natural Supernaturalism is quite well known and even used as a textbook," he said, "but it never seems to have attracted the acclaim of its predecessor."

What accounts for its relative lack of esteem? "The title, Natural Supernaturalism, is harder to pronounce than The Mirror and the Lamp, which is a title quoted from William Butler Yeats," he said, smiling. "People get the title wrong in all sorts of ways. It's rare to find someone getting it right."

Abrams also was surprised by the success of the Norton Anthology. He was approached by the president of W.W. Norton to edit a volume to be used in survey courses in literature, modeled on a course he taught at Cornell.

"We expected to sell some thousands of copies," he said. "What happened was inconceivable. It took off and sold all over the world. We tried to represent the greatest of English literary works in two volumes. And over the years, the bigger it's gotten, the better it's sold."

Abrams is working on a new project in an area he thinks has been largely neglected, which he calls "The Fourth Dimension of a Poem." It's the focus of his essay in The Persistence of Poetry, and it harks back to his wartime research in Harvard's Psycho-Acoustic Lab.

The dimensions of poetry are the look of print on the page, the sound of the words, the meaning of the words and -- the fourth -- the physical act of articulating the words, he explained. In his essay, he writes, "... when we read a poem slowly and with close attention, even if we read it silently to ourselves, the act involves -- often below the level of distinct awareness -- the feel of enunciating the words of the poem by remembered, imagined, or incipient movements and tactile sensations in the organs of speech, that is, in the lungs, throat, mouth, tongue and lips." This feature "is essential to the full experience of a poem," he adds, and "has been neglected in literary criticism.

"If you lose that dimension of poetry, if you read quickly to get through a poem to what it means, you have missed the body of the poem," he said. The fourth dimension is vibrantly displayed in the way Robert Pinsky articulates his poems or in the speeches of the great black orators like Martin Luther King Jr. and even in rap music, Abrams noted. "Rap is far from an abstract, dematerialized mode of utterance. I hate a lot of rap because it's bad stuff, but it does emphasize the articulatory aspect of the words."

Abrams describes reading Keats' poetry aloud as "a richly sensuous oral activity" which feels "like honey on the tongue." Amidst the noise of 21st century infotainment media, a Romantic poet like Keats may be as hard to hear as a man trying to shout words into a radio over the noise of tanks and bombs.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The quotable Abrams
On deconstruction theory: "When something startlingly new comes up, people -- young people, especially -- seize it. You can't complain about that. I think its heyday has passed, but it's had an effect and will continue to have an effect."

On predicting trends in literary theory: "If you learn one thing from having lived through decades of changing views, it is that all predictions are necessarily false."

On literature: "We are human, and nothing is more interesting to us than humanity. The appeal of literature is that it is so thoroughly a human thing -- by, for and about human beings. If you lose that focus, you obviate the source of the power and permanence of literature."

On Robert Frost: "He always violated your expectations. ... He was a character."

On his student Harold Bloom: "Indisputably a genius and one of the great flamboyant characters of our era."

On Shakespeare: "It's amazing how, age after age, in country after country, and in all languages, Shakespeare emerges as incomparable."

On the movie "Shakespeare in Love": "Fun. Good Stoppard. But I didn't recognize Shakespeare. They made him out to be a kind of 19th century esthete."

On the "death of literature": "You always hear about it, but it's always grossly exaggerated. The survival of artistic modes in which we recognize ourselves, identify ourselves and place ourselves will survive as long as humanity survives."

From: http://www.news.cornell.edu/Chronicle/99/6.10.99/Abrams.html

[ 本帖最后由怀抱花朵的孩子于 2006-5-28 23:40 编辑 ]

作者: 怀抱花朵的孩子 时间: 2006-5-22 23:47
I have read M.H. Abrams' The Mirror and the Lamp: Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition, and I am very fond of this book. but I felt that I have no time and ability to write a comment about it. and I think it's very important to recommend Abrams and his book to you guys. So I pasted this passage to you hoping for any help to you.

[ 本帖最后由怀抱花朵的孩子于 2006-5-23 23:06 编辑 ]

作者: Eternity's 时间: 2006-5-23 20:06
never heard of him, Abrams

作者: jiannan 时间: 2006-5-24 23:28
well i just read his the Mirror adn the lamp chapter 1, in which he propose four elements of art, that is , the universe, the work, the artist and the audience.
however, from the first chapter, i think he just trace the whole literary history of the western world, and classify it according their emphasis , that is to say, the Mimetic theories from the Greek to Renaissance, and the representative including such famous person as Plato, Aristotle, and the one who talking about the sublime( sorry, i forgot his name), Young ,Lessing ; and the pragmatic theories , the expressive theories and the objective theories.
but i realy think that Abrams is very great. and i hope i can read through the whole book.

作者: 怀抱花朵的孩子 时间: 2006-5-25 10:48

原帖由 jiannan 于 2006-5-24 23:28 发表
well i just read his the Mirror adn the lamp chapter 1, in which he propose four elements of art, that is , the universe, the work, the artist and the audience.
however, from the first chapter, ...

the one who talking about the sublime is Longinus.you can get it in http://www.reeds.com.cn/viewthre ... &extra=page%3D1

well i just read his the Mirror adn the lamp chapter 1, in which he propose four elements of art, that is , the universe, the work, the artist and the audience

You got it! His four elements is very important for this book.as you say : i think he just trace the whole literary history of the western world, and classify it according their emphasis . He give little original comments but creative narrations about the theories of so mang great writers and literary theorists. but you should pay attention to his narrative strategies and his own emphasis. many pepole say that Abrams give a very distinct narration about Romantic theories, but I think that when he was pursuing distinction he is (and he have to) avoiding talking about some important actualities. For example,When you continue your reading you'll find that Abrams didn't mention anything about Wordsworth's emphasis on contemplation but "spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings".
I have said that "His four elements is very important for this book", When you read the next chapters of this book you'll wonder about this view. but it's true, Romantic literature theory is so complicated that Abrams have to adopt this kind of narrative style, but even so he also have to choose some emphasis points.
I also think he is very very great. but i don't know how many poems and original viewpoints of these great writers have you read. if not so much you'll read this book with agony,cause even have read some of thier poems and articles, I still feel very hard to absolutely understand what he is talking about,I have to read some chapters again and again. I think you should read some poems and grasp some basic concepts. After that you'll feel easier to follow him.

[ 本帖最后由怀抱花朵的孩子于 2006-5-25 10:51 编辑 ]

欢迎光临芦笛外国文学论坛 (http://reeds.com.cn/)